News & Reviews

Stageloft's ‘Sea Marks’ is a
romance with soul

By Paul Kolas Telegram and Gazette Reviewer
February 13, 2007- FOUR STARS

STURBRIDGE— Not only has the winter been unusually kind this year (so far at least), but the 2007 local theater season has blessed us with some unusually fine productions. The latest gem is Stageloft Repertory Theater’s beautifully written and acted presentation of Gardner McKay’s tender and bittersweet love story, “Sea Marks,” which cast a quiet spell on Saturday night’s audience.

McKay was originally an actor in the late ’50s and early ’60s, best known for his stint in a TV series called “Adventures in Paradise.” Dissatisfied with the celebrity spotlight, he became a world-wide traveler and eventually settled down to writing novels and two plays, “Untold Damage” and “Sea Marks.”

“Sea Marks” is a lushly lyrical account of two star-crossed lovers who rigorously embody the term “opposites attract.” Colm Primrose is a lifelong fisherman living and working on Cliffhorn Heads, a rustic island off the west coast of Ireland. Timothea Stiles is an ambitious young publisher’s assistant in thriving Liverpool. Inspired by a
chance meeting at a friend’s wedding, Colm begins writing florid letters to Timothea, telling her, “Around here, you don’t see a
girl like that.”

Even though Timothea doesn’t remember meeting Colm at the wedding, she is entranced by his wonderfully evocative descriptions of the sea (“The beach isn’t pretty, but it is filled with gray stones that the sea turns black,”) and reciprocates with details about her life in Liverpool, working for Mr. Blackstone.

Letters are exchanged over a period of 18 months, distilled into roughly the opening 20 minutes of the play. It’s a risky, epistolary device that somehow works because Mark Axelson and Robbin Joyce bring Colm and Timothea to life during this long-distance courtship.

When they finally meet, the chemistry between the two actors is palpable. They are convincingly awkward and shy, fumbling their way to something resembling their letter-written eloquence. Colm is particularly chagrined about his inability to express himself so poetically eye to eye with this lovely woman. Timothea, for her part, tries to soothe his nervousness and lack of confidence by telling him what a natural poet he is.

Once Colm decides to move in with Timothea, the bloom of love begins to take its toll. Can Colm adjust to life in the big city? As much as he loves Timothea, and as hard as she tries to make him feel he belongs with her, going so far as to have the non-personal parts of his letters to her published as a volume of poetry, can she keep him from going back to the sea? As Colm confesses to her, his “soul has been too long off the water.”

But as solemn and pensive as much of “Sea Marks” may be, it’s sprinkled with abundant wit and humor, including the before and after of their first love-making encounter. Axelson’s performance is extraordinarily rich, full of warmth, humor and sad Irish soul. You can feel how torn he is inside, pulled one way by his love for the sea and the other by his love for this wonderful woman.

It’s a restlessly brilliant piece of acting, well joined to Joyce’s luminous portrayal of Timothea. Joyce beautifully conveys both
Timothea’s confidence and vulnerability, as she tries so valiantly to find a middle ground to make things work between them. To
see two actors work in such remarkable tandem, armed with lilting dialogue and director Edward Cornely’s steady hand, is exhilarating. You owe it to yourself to see this wisp of magic.